The Potato Plan

I’m a bulk cooker and one of the types of sessions I do is potatoes. Many people are surprised by this because they assume that potatoes don’t freeze successfully. I assumed the same thing at first but after years of experimenting I’ve found that they are one of the easiest and most versatile foods in my repertoire.

When they go on sale I buy at least 20#, frequently 60# or more. I never buy potatoes unless they are on sale and I never have to deal with watching them slowly go bad in the dark recesses of my pantry because I can’t use them fast enough.

Remember, you cannot successfully freeze raw potatoes. If you try, you will find you have black potatoes when you thaw them for use. Some people do blanch their potatoes before freezing and finish cooking after they thaw. Most prefer to cook and freeze. Part of this is personal preference, part will be the recipes you use.

You may decide to handle yours differently but here’s what I do. This is not intended to be a plan for you to follow exactly. It is a basic skeleton to guide you through the procedure but, because every family is different, you will choose your own recipes to use in the plan.

Turn the oven on and let it preheat while you’re preparing the potatoes. Scrub them, pierce them, and sort them by size. Place some of medium and large on baking sheets by size and start baking. The large size will take an hour or more at 400 degrees; the smaller ones will take a little less time. Reserve the remaining medium and large potatoes for oven baked fries and potato wedges.

For wedges, cut unpeeled medium sized potatoes into 6-8 wedges lengthwise. Coat them with olive or canola oil. Don’t use a lot, just enough to coat. Add whatever spices you wish and toss until evenly coated. I add a little sugar to the spices to help brown and crisp the wedges. Place on non-stick baking sheets or baking sheets sprayed with non-stick spray; bake at 400 degrees for 30 minutes. Place on brown paper bags or paper towels to cool. Place on clean cookie sheets and freeze solid. Place in labeled freezer bags and return to the freezer.

For oven fries, use the reserved large potatoes, peeling or not as you wish. Cut into fries. I use 1/2″ fries; the size of your fries will determine your baking time. If your fries are not super-crisp, cover them with cold water and let them set for 45-60 minutes; drain, dry well. Toss with olive or canola oil, add spices and sugar and toss again. Place on baking sheet sprayed with non-stick spray and bake at 475 degrees for 20 minutes. Place on brown paper bags or paper towels to cool. Place on clean cookie sheets and freeze solid. Place in labeled freezer bags and return to the freezer.

I use the small potatoes to make mashed potatoes. There are two ways to do this. If the skins are in good shape and I want to use them to make potato skin appetizers, I bake them in the oven like the larger sizes. When they come out I cut them in half (the long way) and scoop the flesh out into a bowl. I place the skins on a baking sheet, fill with whatever additions I want (not sour cream, it tends to separate and become watery when frozen by itself), flash freeze, wrap well, label, and return to the freezer. If I want very crispy potato skins, I simply freeze them empty.

If the skins are not in good enough shape to use, I boil them in their skins, drain, cut in half (the short way), and place in a ricer*, cut side down. I don’t have to take time to peel or mash them; the ricer does both for me in one motion. Add whatever ingredients you wish to the pulp (sour cream, cream cheese, butter, salt and pepper, garlic, onion, other seasonings, etc), freeze in meal-sized portions, making sure to wrap well and label. (Note that I do add sour cream before freezing when it is mixed with other ingredients.)

As the larger potatoes come out of the oven, I let them cool enough to handle.

I pick out the nicest looking medium sized potatoes for twice baked potatoes. Don’t let them get too cool or it will be hard to scrape the pulp out of the skin. Slit lengthways. While still warm, scoop the pulp out, leaving a thin layer of pulp in the skin. Mash the pulp up and combine with anything you wish. I usually add sour cream or cottage cheese (to make the filling creamier and a little tangy) followed by seasonings such as finely minced onion or garlic (or use the powders), dill weed, or celery flakes. I’ve also varied them by using a little Italian seasoning or taco seasoning. If you use dried herbs, make sure the pulp is moist enough to rehydrate them; add a little milk if you need to. Refill the skins with the pulp, flash freeze, wrap, label, and return to the freezer.

I pick out the nicest looking large potatoes for baked potatoes or loaded (stuffed) potatoes. After they have cooled completely, I place them on a baking sheet, flash freeze, bag, label, and return to the freezer. I don’t care for the texture of microwave baked potatoes but previously oven baked potatoes are fine when they’ve been re-warmed in the microwave.

For loaded potatoes, use large potatoes and freeze them whole after they have been baked. (If you wish, you can make the loaded potatoes first and freeze them). Slit lengthwise and place in individual serving bowls. Possible toppings are limited only by your imagination. We especially like:

  • Taco – taco flavored crumbled ground beef, chopped tomatoes, chopped onion, shredded lettuce, sour cream
  • Ham and Cheese – shredded or coarsely ground ham, shredded Swiss cheese
  • Pizza – Crumbled Italian sausage, shredded Mozzarella cheese, green pepper, mushrooms, pizza sauce (Can also use pepperoni, shredded chicken, shredded ham, or hamburger)
  • Roast Beef – shredded roast beef, shredded Cheddar cheese, mushrooms
  • Chili and Cheese – canned or made chili (not too soupy), shredded Cheddar, sour cream
  • BLT – crumbled crisp-fried bacon, chopped tomatoes, and shredded lettuce with a little sour cream if you want

The remaining medium and large sized potatoes (with the skins that didn’t look so good) are peeled, shredded or chopped, and used for things such as potato pancakes, hash brown casseroles, and soups.

Really, anything is fair game. Just let your imagination run wild.

*A ricer is a very handy little kitchen utensil that allows you to make mashed potatoes without really mashing them. It is composed of a cylinder about 2 1/2″ high and 3 1/2″ wide. The bottom of the cylinder looks like a sieve and the top is open. The handle is hinged and the top part has a flat disk attached that fits into the top of the cylinder. Place your cooked potato half in the cylinder, cut side down, and squeeze. The pulp goes through the sieve and the skin remains in the cylinder. It lets you make mashed potatoes with a nice, somewhat lighter texture than if you mashed them (Unless, of course, you stir them to death after you’ve riced them.) You can also just put whole peeled cooked potatoes in it. Think over-sized garlic press and you might get a better picture of it. You can find them in most kitchen supply sections.

Potato Plan page 1 | 2

© Wanda A. Carter; Used by permission

Wanda is a member of Menus4Moms™ Yahoo group and has been bulk cooking for years.

About Mary Ann

Mary Ann Kelley has been creating meal plans online for over 15 years, first as part of TheHomeSchoolMom's cooking resources for busy moms and later on Menus4Moms, which has been highlighted by "Diner's Journal," The New York Times' Blog on Dining Out, and PBS Parents' "Kitchen Explorer."

Mary Ann loves cooking and she loves planning/organizing, so meal planning is a natural intersection of the two. She believes her mission for the meal plans is being fulfilled when visitors let her know that she has helped them save time and money by teaching them to plan ahead and become more efficient in the kitchen.

When Mary Ann is not cooking, she enjoys reading, researching genealogy, and traveling.


  1. I’m really excited about this! I’m going to do Once a Month Cooking soon, but was a bit nervous that I would have PLENTY of entrees, but not enough side dishes. These ideas look great!

  2. I was just wondering how you reheat the wedges or fries and at what temp for how long?
    thank you

    • Hi Lisa – I usually reheat similar to the way I would reheat frozen fries from the store, at about 450 degrees. The time would depend on the quantity, but between 12-20 minutes.

  3. This really sounds great, practical and delicious. I´d love to be able to cook and prepare like this. Only, I don´t dare to start a project like this, since I would have no clue how long it would take. Does this take a full morning? How many kilo´s of patatoes do you use? Do you make a monthsupply? I´d be very interested…

    • Hi Yvette – This post was reprinted with permission from Wanda Carter, but she is not a regular contributor on the blog and probably won’t see your question. She doesn’t put exact amounts because it really depends on how much you want to do. You can buy and prepare as many or as few potatoes as fits your needs. Wanda buys in 20 lb. increments, which would be around 9 kilos. She mentioned that she often buys up to 60 lbs. when they are on sale, so that would be around 27 kilos. That is a LOT of potatoes and would likely take all day to prepare. The bottom line is that you just have to decide how much you want to do of each dish and purchase to that scale. If you decide to prepare the potatoes, let us know how it goes!

    • Hi Yvette,

      I just saw your question (I’ve had some major health issues during the past year and haven’t been on the computer much.) but I wanted to let you know that Mary Ann was right on target with what she told you. If I’m only doing 20# I figure on about 3 hours. I have a temperamental oven and I have better luck only baking 15# at a time. For 60# I plan on 5-6 hours. A lot will depend on how complicated your recipes are. Of the ones I do, the French fries and the twice baked are probably the most time consuming. I always freeze a good amount of the potatoes whole and that takes no prep time, just some cooling off time before I stick them in the freezer. If I’m doing a lot of casseroles, that adds to the time because I bake them before freezing in portion sizes. If you want to shorten your prep time, cook your potatoes first, then assemble your dishes like casseroles and soups, and freeze before cooking. With my current health issues it has been difficult to stay on my feet for lengthy periods so I do short sessions with just 1 or 2 potato dishes at a time. And having well stocked freezers has been a life saver when I haven’t been able to cook at all.

      • Hiya, I’ve just read your blog about freezing potatoes – firstly, I’m sorry you have been unwell – been there myself over the last three years and the food that I have cooked and prepared when able, then frozen, has been a great help. I, too, freeze potatoes. We didn’t like the roasted ones much but the mashed potatoes were great and re-heated either in the oven (sometimes with grated cheese on top) and sometimes in the microwave. I am just about to try to do some fried potato skins – I regularly have family over and I’m not in the best health to do too much at a time so it becomes a military operation – lists to do, to make, to buy, etc etc. I do hope you are feeling better – I’ve just had my final clear CT scan after three years so am looking forward to many freezing years. God bless. x

Share Your Thoughts


Disclaimer & Disclosure Opinions expressed by contributing authors, commenters and reviewers are solely the responsibility and opinion of the author and do not necessarily represent the views of contains outbound links to websites offering resources related to cooking or the home. may be offered compensation for these links, either in the form of commissions or flat advertising fees. [ Read more ]